Owning our future: how realistic is it, and what can we do about it?

How much control do we want over our career and our business? How much do we really have? And what can we do to have as much control as possible?

These three questions describe one of the most persistent tensions in professional life.

An agency tension

Wendy Smith and Marianne Lewis, two of the leading scholars of paradox in organisations, set out their theory in "Toward a theory of paradox: a dynamic equilibrium model of organizing", published in the Academy of Management Review in 2011. They identify four families of paradox that run through organisations. One of them, the organising paradox, emerges when a system must combine competing ways of structuring its action: control and flexibility, direction and empowerment, stability and change. Their central point is that these tensions are persistent. Each pole is legitimate, and pursuing one permanently at the expense of the other produces dysfunction. The work consists of holding both in a dynamic equilibrium, adjusting the balance as conditions evolve.

Translated to the individual, the organising paradox becomes an agency tension: the pull between our desire to direct our own path and the need to respond to an environment we do not control. A tension of this kind has no final solution. It can be managed, and managed again each time the context shifts. To manage it well, we first need to understand the forces acting on each side.

The structure we live in

Anthony Giddens offered one of the most useful readings of the relationship between individuals and the systems they inhabit. In The Constitution of Society (1984), he describes structure as the rules and resources that organise social life, and he proposes what he calls the duality of structure. Structure constrains action and, at the same time, makes it possible. We also reproduce it through our own conduct, often without noticing.

For a professional, the structure is the business context in which we operate. As employees, it is the organisation, its governance, its culture and the sector it competes in. As entrepreneurs, it is the market, the expectations of clients and the dynamics of our industry. This context conditions what we can do, and it also provides the resources through which we act.

The practical consequence is that agency begins with reading the structure. Our task is to understand what it imposes on us, to identify the degree of freedom it leaves, and to use that freedom to build a differentiated position in our personal market. If we ignore the structure, our position becomes fragile. If we let the structure define it entirely, we become indistinguishable from everyone else operating within the same constraints.

Pierre Bourdieu adds a less comfortable observation. Through the concept of habitus, he shows that structure also lives inside us. Family, education and professional trajectory leave durable dispositions that shape how we perceive situations and which options feel natural. Some moves appear obvious; others never enter our field of vision. Some of the limits we blame on circumstances are in fact inside us. When we recognise them, we gain more room to choose.

Our share of free will

Philosophers have argued about free will for some two and a half thousand years without settling the matter, and it would be imprudent to attempt it in a newsletter. Isaiah Berlin offers a more workable question. In "Two Concepts of Liberty" (1958), he distinguishes negative liberty, the absence of interference by others, from positive liberty, the capacity to be one's own master and to act from purposes we recognise as our own.

The distinction is useful for any professional. Negative liberty is largely determined by the structure, in the autonomy a role allows or the room a market leaves. Positive liberty is built from within. It depends on clarity about what we want to achieve and why, on values held firmly enough to guide our choices, and on capabilities strong enough to turn intention into action. Two executives in the same company, with the same formal autonomy, can exercise very different degrees of self-mastery.

This matters for our personal brand. When we act deliberately, guided and empowered by our knowledge and our worldview, we gain gravitas and influence. When we fail to do so, we fade into an undifferentiated crowd and become easy to replace.

Using and extending our agency

Albert Bandura, in his account of social cognitive theory from an agentic perspective, describes three modes through which people exercise influence over their lives. Personal agency is the direct control we exert over our own actions and their immediate conditions. Proxy agency is the influence we exercise through others who hold the resources, expertise or power we lack. Collective agency is the influence a group achieves through a shared belief in its ability to act together.

This framework shows how the space of agency can grow. Personal agency is the territory we govern directly, and it deserves to be used fully before we lament its limits. Proxy agency extends our reach through relationships, such as a sponsor who brings our proposal to the executive committee or a partner who opens a new market. Collective agency extends it further, through alliances, professional communities and networks capable of modifying the context itself.

This is where our personal brand plays a decisive role. People lend their influence to those they trust, and they follow those they find credible. A strong reputation turns our relationships into a greater capacity to act, and with it we can begin to influence the structure we live in.

From understanding to practice

Henry Mintzberg distinguished between deliberate and emergent strategy. Deliberate strategy is what we intend. Emergent strategy is the pattern that forms in our actions as we respond to what happens along the way. The strategy we actually realise is always a combination of the two.

Applied to a career or a business, this suggests a discipline in three movements. The first is to define a deliberate strategy that takes into account both the structure in which we operate and our own long-term goals. The second is to review periodically how that strategy has really been deployed; twice a year is a reasonable rhythm. The review compares the path we intended with the path we have followed, makes the emergent strategy visible, and establishes how much of it was determined by the structure, through changes in our company, our sector, the market or society that have reshaped our activity. The third movement is to fine-tune the strategy in light of what the review reveals.

Humberto Maturana and Francisco Varela described this kind of adaptation in living systems. They called it autopoiesis, the capacity of a living system to produce and renew its own components continuously while remaining itself. The environment perturbs the system and triggers change, and the system responds according to its own nature. Perturbations never dictate the response. As professionals, we need to adapt in the same way. We respond to the changes in our context, and we decide how to respond from who we are.

There is also value in surrendering to the structure. Mintzberg saw emergent strategy as a form of learning, the way an organisation discovers what works while it acts. When we tune in with the context, it presents us with opportunities no plan could have anticipated, such as a role that opens after a reorganisation or a client need that appears with a change in the market. If we remain open to them, we reap the benefits of flexibility, the other pole of the organising paradox. Some of the most valuable positions in a career are found by following what the context offers.

Both movements, adjusting our strategy and following what the context offers, require an anchor. Each review will reveal changes in the context that call for adjustments, and without a stable reference the sum of those adjustments can dissolve who we are without us noticing. That anchor is our centre of gravity: our moral stand, our long-term vision of success and our long-term strategic goals. It allows us to evaluate every adjustment with one question. Does this change bring us closer to the position we want to hold, in a way that remains faithful to what we stand for? Tactics, offer and even aspects of positioning can evolve, while the centre of gravity preserves our identity throughout the process.

Our success strategy, and our personal brand with it, is co-authored with all our stakeholders and heavily influenced by the context in which we operate. The control we can hold is real, and it grows with our understanding of that interplay. Understanding it, and adjusting with agility as it changes, is what sustains our ability to succeed.

If you want to explore how much of your own path is truly yours, and how to extend that share, I would be glad to talk.

Book an exploratory meeting with Giuseppe

Siguiente
Siguiente

On the tensions of becoming